Grinch alert, fake life raft & EPIRB releases!

Ben Ellison

Ben Ellison

Panbo editor, publisher & chief bottlewasher from 4/2005 until 8/2018, and now excited to have Ben Stein as very able publisher, webmaster, and editing colleague. Panbo is going to the next level in 2019 and beyond.

1 Response

  1. norse says:

    If I had one of these, I would check it. If I had an investigative journalist, I would have him check this story. I have no reason to doubt this story, but there’s not much info to be had and all of it is coming from one source. Why would someone bother to fake a cheap non-consumer item that has a limited market? What would be the business plan for that? I’d like to know where Hammar found the fakes and how many they found. They say they tested “several”. Is that several as in two, three, four? And that none of them worked to the Solas spec. But they say nothing at all about the interior mechanism. Was there one that was inferior or was it totally non-functional?
    Here is a web page which gives a good idea of what’s supposed to be inside and how it works:
    http://www.nordmarine.nf.net/NORDMar/images/releaseunits/Dwnld%20-%20Datasheet%20Hammar%20H20.pdf
    It also describes Hammar’s quality testing process and that reassures me. (It seems many companies these days outsource production to other countries then take no responsibility for lack of quality control).
    The only incident I found involving this product was the Empress of the North grounding in 2007, and in that case the manual pumps were faulty, not the H2O release mechanisms.
    http://www.professionalmariner-digital.com/professionalmariner/sample/?pg=42
    http://www.taproot.com/wordpress/2007/09/27/marne-safety-alert-lifeboat-release/
    Since these H2O units are supposed to be replaced every two years, a company in that business could clean up the old ones and recycle them as new (that seems more likely than counterfeiting). I would be curious to know where the bad units got into the distribution channel. Anyone would could make one of these units would also be able to print the manuals and labels too; those PDFs are on Hammar’s website.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published.